June 24, 2005

Germans and Film Reviews

I've been wondering for a while whether the lack of critical reviews in the Japanese media is "unique" or whether I was just wrongly assuming the universality of press interest in judging artistic products. But here now are the Germans, who are up in arms over a War of the Worlds press-ban. (And by the way, having a press ban is always a sign that your movie is terrible.)

While we're on the topic, does anyone know of any other country besides Japan that does not have institutionalized cultural reviews? Is this a East Asian social-network concept, a developing nation concept, or just another sign of a weak media dependent upon its advertisers?

Posted by marxy at June 24, 2005 11:43 AM
Comments

I'm reading it as the finding any sort of issue the press can unite on.

If the press can manage to move like a pack then they can enjoy and demonstrate their power. You know the old saying "they can make you and they can break your".

I would guess the uniquely German twist is less their own media "uniqueness" than the overall issue rationalizing Cruise's outspoken opinions and the German state's position on Scientology being a dangerous cult.

And of course there's Spielberg's Munich Olympics Massacre film in production this week.

Posted by: ndkent at July 4, 2005 12:20 PM