« Blogging to Commence.... Soon! | Main | SXSW and the Paradox of Choice »

March 19, 2007

An Odd Thing about Airplane Movies

On my flight to SFO from NRT, the communal movie reel (United 747s are still pre-personal TV screens) offered us a special treat before each film: a short clip of film critics Ebert and Roper (sans Ebert, unfortunately) reviewing the motion picture coming up next. But seeing that airlines cannot afford to purchase good films for their passengers, the non-Roper Ebert-replacement invariably gave the film a "thumbs down." (Roper likes everything.)

In a world with too many product choices, critics help us filter out the wheat from the chaff by providing commentary that we either accept/reject as expert opinion or views we trust on the hunch that the critic's tastes resemble our own. Stuck in an airplane with no choices in films other than the three pre-selected for our viewing, I do not know how important it is to know that Harold Ramis (guest critic) did not like Man of the Year. I mean, he was right - Robin Williams' faux-Jon Stewart jokes lacked satirical bite - but I am not sure what I gained out of hearing his negative impression right before I hunkered down to kill two hours.

Is American culture critical beyond the functional value of criticism? Or was this just a misplaced filler segment?

Posted by marxy at March 19, 2007 5:03 PM

Trackback Pings

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.pliink.com/mt/mt-tb.cgi/236

Comments

I'd go with Option B. I'll make a slightly less sweeping wild guess: the producers of the Ebert show show are struggling with ways to syndicate it now that Siskel is dead and Ebert is sick, and since airlines seem ready to bundle any old crap into their in-flight content (why is there so much light jazz on just about every airline?) I guess they decided that was a good idea. I don't know if I'm like most viewers, but I tend to read reviews after watching a movie to see what other people thought of it. Maybe the movie review would have worked better as a kind of conversation starter after the film.

Posted by: Adamu at March 19, 2007 5:37 PM

Hardly. The sheer quantity of shitty movies on the market certainly warrants the degree of negative criticism most films receive. I mean, come on, did you really need a critic to warn you about "Man of the Year?" Airplane movies are a poor example (last flight I had the unusual privilege of seeing two good movies, "The Queen" and some Spanish drama), but I think harsh criticism is a necessary step in setting a higher standard for the film industry. Given, not every movie can be excellent, but still, even movies that received rave reviews (e.g. Babel) are often thoroughly mediocre. If anything, we're not critical enough.

Posted by: Andrew at March 19, 2007 11:50 PM

(hehe, told you ages ago you'd be better having two different blogs but you guys mocked my suggestion. guess it missed one crucial element.)

Posted by: alin at March 20, 2007 1:38 AM

I have to give this review of a review a thumbs up, but sadly the thing seems to be just filler.

Posted by: john at March 20, 2007 3:10 AM

hey marxy i think your new ep is really awesome i listen to it all the time. (couldn't find your email address so leaving message in comments)

Posted by: toby at March 20, 2007 5:12 AM

everyone just thinks they are a critic, and that their opinions are worth something. credibility is solely based on the height of ones soap box. wait, im off topic.

you should fly american airlines. not only cause its got an awesome name. but because its cheap, and has personally "tv"s..

Posted by: trevor at March 20, 2007 8:45 AM

The only thing I get out of movie reels is a sense of cultural displacement nowadays. Seeing as I rarely get a chance to see movies outside of my 3LDK environs here in Tokyo, I look forward to the a transpacific flight and it's four-six hours of average movies that haven't even hit a first run in Japan.

Posted by: shiny floor occupant at March 20, 2007 9:13 AM

After spending a year in Osaka in 2000, a time when keeping in touch with American culture was a lot more difficult than it is now (and it was far from my mind anyway), the flight home on United was a surreal experience. I found myself laughing my ass off at Chip N Dale Rescue Rangers just because I hadn't been exposed to those corny jokes for so long. I don't know why I'm mentioning this, but the comments reminded me of that experience.

Posted by: Adamu at March 20, 2007 1:40 PM

Who doesn't crack up a bit at Monterey Jack's trademark "ch-ch-ch-cheeEEEeese!"

Posted by: Rory P. Wavekrest at March 20, 2007 7:08 PM

Presumably the idea is to help you decide whether you want to spend the next couple hours watching the movie or doing something else, like typing on a laptop or reading a book or destroying some vertebrae in an attempt to sleep or staring at the folded tray in front of you and contemplating Nietzsche and the stabbing of the kid who's kicking your seat to the beat of the Avril Lavigne emanating from their headphones. And trevor, JetBlue>American.

Posted by: bhauth at March 29, 2007 3:02 PM

Post a comment

Thanks for signing in, . Now you can comment. (sign out)

(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)


Remember me?